PhotoCraftPhotoCraft

Layered editing guide

Which free layer-based photo editor should you use?

PhotoCraft is the strongest free layer-based photo editor in this set for users who want a Photoshop-style workflow, local PSD/PSB files, and an open-source implementation. Affinity Photo is stronger for RAW photography, HDR, and a polished photography toolkit. GIMP is the more established general-purpose FOSS editor, Krita is the painting specialist, and Photopea is the fastest browser option. Choose by the layers and outputs your work actually needs, not by a generic feature count.

By the ArtCraft maintainers11 min read
Exploded stack of photographic layers, masks, and a blue adjustment curve on a concrete studio table
A useful layer-based editor preserves more than a flattened image: it keeps the decisions editable.
01 / Direct answer

Key takeaways

  • A layer-based editor keeps image content, masks, adjustments, effects, type, and vectors editable instead of merging every change into pixels.
  • PhotoCraft fits open-source PSD work with layers, masks, adjustment layers, layer styles, smart objects, type, and vectors.
  • Affinity Photo fits layered photography with RAW, HDR, batch tools, and unlimited layers.
  • GIMP fits mature general image manipulation, Krita fits painting and illustration, and Photopea fits browser access.
  • PhotoCraft is early alpha; test complex PSD files, fonts, colour modes, and large documents before relying on it.
02 / Comparison

Which free layer-based editor fits each workflow?

PhotoCraft fits Photoshop-style PSD and layer work. Affinity fits photography. GIMP fits broad FOSS image manipulation, Krita fits painting, and Photopea fits browser-first editing.

Which free layer-based editor fits each workflow?
EditorLicensePlatformsPricingPSD workflowBest for
PhotoCraftMIT OR Apache-2.0macOS, Windows, Linux, FreeBSD, WebFreeLayered PSD/PSB read and writeUsers who want a familiar Photoshop-style workspace, local editing, and an inspectable open-source editor
Affinity PhotoProprietaryWindows, macOSFree with a Canva account; premium Canva AI optionalImports layered PSD files with feature-dependent fidelityPhotographers who need RAW development, HDR, batch tools, and a polished non-Adobe workflow
GIMPGPL open sourceWindows, macOS, Linux, BSDFreePSD import/export with compatibility limitsUsers who value a mature general-purpose open-source editor, community plug-ins, and scripting
KritaGPL open sourceWindows, macOS, Linux, AndroidFreePSD import/export with painting-first constraintsIllustrators, concept artists, and painters who need brushes, stabilizers, and animation tools
PhotopeaProprietary web appBrowserFree core editor with optional paid upgradesImports and exports PSD with feature-dependent behaviorQuick browser access when installation, offline work, or native GPU performance are not required

Comparison reviewed 2026-11-12. Pricing and licensing can change; verify each vendor’s current terms before purchase.

03 / Layered editing guide

What is a layer-based photo editor?

A layer-based photo editor keeps separate image, text, vector, mask, adjustment, and effect layers in a document so each decision can be revised without flattening the entire result.

This differs from a basic photo editor that applies one global adjustment or decoration to a single bitmap. A useful layered workflow includes stack order, opacity, blend modes, groups, masks, clipping, editable type, and output that preserves the document structure.

The layer model also determines portability. PSD and PSB files are common exchange formats, but applications implement features differently. A file can open successfully and still lose or flatten the exact feature you need to edit.

04 / Layered editing guide

Which layer features matter most?

Prioritise the features used in repeated work: masks, adjustment layers, layer styles, smart objects or live filters, editable type, vector shapes, groups, blend modes, clipping, colour management, and reliable save/reopen behaviour.

  • Raster layers for pixels and photographs.
  • Layer masks and clipping masks for non-destructive isolation.
  • Adjustment layers for curves, levels, colour balance, and selective edits.
  • Live filters or smart filters for reversible effects.
  • Layer styles for shadows, glows, bevels, and strokes.
  • Editable type and vector shapes for graphic layout.
  • Groups and blend modes for complex compositions.
05 / Layered editing guide

Why choose PhotoCraft as a layer-based editor?

PhotoCraft offers a Photoshop-style native workspace with layers, masks, 16 adjustment layers, 70+ live-preview filters, smart objects with smart filters, layer styles, type, vectors, brushes, and layered PSD/PSB read/write.

The editor is free and open source under MIT OR Apache-2.0 and runs on macOS, Windows, Linux, FreeBSD, and Web. Its document engine and controls are built as a native application rather than an Electron shell, and the same command model can be driven through the UI, CLI, JSON controls, or MCP.

Those advantages do not remove the alpha caveat. Photoshop plug-ins, generative AI, the deepest typography workflows, and some professional features remain incomplete. The correct test is a representative layered file, not a feature table.

06 / Layered editing guide

Affinity Photo or GIMP for layered editing?

Affinity Photo is the stronger fit for RAW photography, HDR, focus stacking, batch work, and a polished unified photography toolkit. GIMP is the stronger established open-source general editor when scripting and community plug-ins matter more than PSD-focused familiarity.

Affinity’s current official page describes the entire photo toolkit as free with unlimited layers, RAW development, HDR tools, live filters, and PSD import with layer fidelity. Installation currently requires a Canva account, while premium Canva AI features remain optional.

GIMP has a long-established GPL ecosystem and broad image-manipulation coverage. Its interface, plug-in model, and PSD behaviour differ from Photoshop and PhotoCraft, so users should evaluate the actual workflow rather than assuming interchangeable menus.

07 / Layered editing guide

Krita or Photopea for layered image work?

Choose Krita for painting, brushwork, illustration, and animation. Choose Photopea for immediate browser access and lightweight PSD work without installing an application.

Krita’s official positioning is a professional free and open-source painting program. Its brush engines, stabilizers, assistants, and animation tools make it a stronger creative fit for painters than a general photo editor.

Photopea’s advantage is access: no desktop installation and a familiar layer workflow in the browser. Review privacy, storage, account, and performance requirements before using private or very large documents.

08 / Layered editing guide

Which layer-based editors work offline?

PhotoCraft, Affinity Photo, GIMP, and Krita install as local applications and can edit local documents without a browser session. Photopea depends on access to its browser application and service.

Offline capability is only one part of document control. Also check whether accounts, licence checks, cloud sync, telemetry, or update services are required, and whether files leave the machine for AI or collaboration features.

PhotoCraft’s desktop editor and local document workflow do not require an ArtCraft cloud-generation plan. Affinity installation currently requires a Canva account even though editing is performed in the installed application.

09 / Layered editing guide

Which layer-based editor is best for PSD files?

Photoshop remains the PSD reference implementation. PhotoCraft is the most PSD-focused open-source option in this comparison, while Photopea, Affinity, GIMP, and Krita support PSD with feature-dependent fidelity.

PhotoCraft reports matching renders after re-save for 307 of 309 psd-tools files and 169 of 170 mixed ag-psd/psd-tools files. The files are not byte-identical, and unsupported data may be preserved rather than fully editable.

Use the dedicated PSD guide when file exchange is the deciding requirement. This page is about the broader layer model for original image editing and graphic compositions.

10 / Layered editing guide

How should you test a free layered editor?

Open a copy of a real layered document, edit every layer type you depend on, save it, reopen it, and compare both the editable structure and the final render.

  • Test masks, adjustment layers, effects, smart objects, type, vectors, and nested groups.
  • Check the document colour model, bit depth, ICC profile, fonts, and linked assets.
  • Save and reopen in the same editor, then exchange a copy through the other application that must receive it.
  • Test the largest file and the filters used most often.
  • Keep the original file, previous editor, and a documented rollback version.
FAQ

Questions people ask before switching

What is the best free layer-based photo editor?

PhotoCraft is the strongest fit for Photoshop-style, open-source PSD editing. Affinity Photo fits photography, GIMP fits mature general FOSS editing, Krita fits painting, and Photopea fits browser access.

Does PhotoCraft support layers and masks?

Yes. PhotoCraft supports layers, masks, adjustment layers, layer styles, live filters, smart objects, type, and vector layers, with early-alpha limitations for some complex workflows.

Which free editor is best for PSD layers?

PhotoCraft is the most PSD-focused open-source option in this set, but Photoshop remains the reference implementation. Test feature-level compatibility before treating any alternative as a production replacement.

Is Affinity Photo really free?

Affinity’s current official page describes the full photo-editing toolkit as free. Installation requires a Canva account, and premium Canva AI capabilities are optional.

Should illustrators use Krita instead?

Krita is usually the better fit for illustration, painting, brushwork, and animation. PhotoCraft is oriented more closely toward layered photo and PSD editing.

Open source · Free

Try PhotoCraft on your own files.

Download the desktop build, keep your source documents, and compare the layers and output against your current workflow.

Sources and further reading

We use primary vendor and project sources for product features, licensing, and platform claims. PhotoCraft-specific technical details come from its public repository and release documentation.

  1. PhotoCraft source, documentation, and current limitations
  2. PhotoCraft v0.23.1 downloads, release notes, and checksums
  3. Affinity Photo official product page
  4. GIMP official project page
  5. Krita official project page
  6. Photopea online editor