PhotoCraftPhotoCraft

Head-to-head comparison

PhotoCraft vs Affinity Photo: which editor fits your work?

Affinity Photo is the better fit for photographers who need RAW development, HDR, focus stacking, batch tools, and a polished local toolkit at no editor cost. PhotoCraft is the better fit for users who want an open-source, inspectable Photoshop-style editor with layered PSD/PSB read/write and no mandatory document subscription. Affinity is more mature for photography; PhotoCraft offers greater code ownership and Linux support but remains early alpha. Choose by the work you perform, not by price alone.

By the ArtCraft maintainers12 min read
Comparison still life with layered photographic sheets and a camera lens surrounded by black-and-white prints
Affinity is the photography-led toolkit; PhotoCraft is the open-source PSD and layered-editing challenger.
01 / Comparison

How do PhotoCraft and Affinity Photo compare?

Affinity wins photography breadth and polish. PhotoCraft wins open-source ownership, local PSD focus, and cross-platform reach. The right pick depends on whether the job is photographic development or layered image construction.

How do PhotoCraft and Affinity Photo compare?
EditorLicensePlatformsPricingPSD workflowBest for
PhotoCraftMIT OR Apache-2.0macOS, Windows, Linux, FreeBSD, WebFreeLayered PSD/PSB read and writeUsers who want a familiar Photoshop-style workspace, local editing, and an inspectable open-source editor
Affinity PhotoProprietaryWindows, macOSFree with a Canva account; premium Canva AI optionalImports layered PSD files with feature-dependent fidelityPhotographers who need RAW development, HDR, batch tools, and a polished non-Adobe workflow

Comparison reviewed 2026-11-14. Pricing and licensing can change; verify each vendor’s current terms before purchase.

02 / Direct answer

Key takeaways

  • Choose Affinity Photo for photography, RAW development, HDR, focus stacking, batch tools, unlimited layers, and a mature interface.
  • Choose PhotoCraft for open-source code, local PSD/PSB work, Linux and FreeBSD support, automation-friendly controls, and operational independence.
  • Affinity is free but currently requires a Canva account to install; optional Canva premium AI features are separate.
  • PhotoCraft’s editor is free without an account; optional ArtCraft cloud-generation plans are separate from local editing.
  • PhotoCraft is early alpha and does not yet match Affinity’s photography depth or mature production coverage.
03 / Head-to-head comparison

Which is better for most people?

For mainstream photography work, Affinity Photo is the safer and more mature choice. For users who need an open-source, local Photoshop-style editor and can validate PSD workflows, PhotoCraft is the more distinctive option.

04 / Head-to-head comparison

What is Affinity Photo?

Affinity Photo is a GPU-accelerated photo editor for Windows and macOS. Its official page describes the full toolkit as free, with RAW development, HDR, focus stacking, batch processing, macros, unlimited layers, live filters, and PSD import.

Affinity is especially strong when the workflow starts with a camera file and moves through develop, retouch, composite, and export. Its tools are designed around professional photography and pixel workflows, with a coherent interface and broad output coverage.

The current download flow requires a Canva account. AI features are connected to Canva plans, while the core photo editor is presented as free. Verify the current account and feature terms before standardising a team on the workflow.

05 / Head-to-head comparison

What is PhotoCraft?

PhotoCraft is a free, open-source image editor written in Rust, with a Photoshop-style workspace, layered PSD/PSB read/write, native GPU compositing, and builds for macOS, Windows, Linux, FreeBSD, and Web.

The current release is v0.23.1. PhotoCraft supports layers, masks, adjustment layers, layer styles, smart objects, live filters, type, vectors, colour management, and brush workflows. Its command engine can also be automated through CLI, JSON controls, and MCP.

The limitation is maturity. PhotoCraft explicitly remains early alpha and does not claim complete Photoshop parity. Its value is strongest where local ownership, source access, PSD experimentation, and cross-platform operation outweigh a larger production photography feature set.

06 / Head-to-head comparison

Which is better for photography?

Affinity Photo is the better choice for RAW development, HDR merging, focus stacking, astrophotography stacking, batch output, and a photography-centric toolkit. PhotoCraft is better treated as a layered image editor, not as a full Camera Raw or Lightroom replacement.

  • Choose Affinity when the job starts with camera RAW files or large photo batches.
  • Choose Affinity for built-in HDR, focus stacking, macros, and photography export workflows.
  • Choose PhotoCraft for layered compositions, PSD interoperability, source ownership, and automation.
  • Keep Photoshop or Affinity available if a particular camera, colour profile, lens, or output pipeline is not yet validated in PhotoCraft.
07 / Head-to-head comparison

Which is better for layers and PSD files?

Affinity is the more mature production application and imports layered PSD files with layer fidelity. PhotoCraft is more directly focused on PSD/PSB read and write and a Photoshop-style editing model, but remains alpha and requires file-specific testing.

PhotoCraft’s current test corpus reports matching renders after re-save for 307 of 309 psd-tools files and 169 of 170 mixed ag-psd/psd-tools files. Re-saved files are not byte-identical, and unsupported data may be preserved rather than fully editable.

Affinity’s strength is the broader polished workflow around imported layers. For a real comparison, exchange a representative file in both directions and inspect editable masks, effects, type, smart objects, and colour management.

08 / Head-to-head comparison

How do pricing and account requirements differ?

Affinity’s photo editor is free but the current download flow requires a Canva account. PhotoCraft is free and open source without an account requirement for the local editor; optional ArtCraft cloud-generation plans are separate.

“Free” is not the only operational cost. Consider account policy, licence updates, team deployment, source availability, plugin ecosystems, support, and the ability to retain a working build. Both products avoid a required Adobe Photoshop subscription in this comparison.

Users should separate the local editor from optional cloud AI in either ecosystem. Verify current terms before purchase or deployment because pricing and account packaging can change.

09 / Head-to-head comparison

Which supports more platforms and offline work?

PhotoCraft publishes macOS, Windows, Linux, FreeBSD, and Web builds. Affinity Photo is available for Windows and macOS. Both desktop applications support local editing, but their account and update requirements differ.

PhotoCraft’s Linux support is the decisive difference for Linux creative workstations. Affinity’s macOS and Windows focus keeps its feature and support scope narrower and more photography-led.

Test installation, colour management, fonts, tablet support, and GPU performance on the target operating system rather than assuming parity across platforms.

10 / Head-to-head comparison

Where does each editor win?

Affinity wins RAW photography, HDR, stacking, batch workflows, and polish. PhotoCraft wins open-source ownership, source inspection, local PSD focus, Linux support, and automation flexibility.

  • Photographer with a RAW-first pipeline: evaluate Affinity Photo first.
  • Open-source user with a layered PSD and Linux workflow: evaluate PhotoCraft first.
  • Team requiring the broadest photographic production coverage: keep Affinity and Adobe in the comparison.
  • User who values source access and reproducible local software: PhotoCraft has the stronger structural advantage.
11 / Head-to-head comparison

What is the honest verdict?

Affinity Photo is the stronger mature photo-production tool. PhotoCraft is the stronger open-source PSD and local-ownership experiment. Neither makes Adobe Photoshop unnecessary for every team.

FAQ

Questions people ask before switching

Is PhotoCraft better than Affinity Photo?

Not universally. Affinity is more mature for photography, RAW, HDR, and polished production workflows. PhotoCraft is better for open-source ownership, PSD-focused local editing, Linux support, and source access.

Is Affinity Photo free?

Affinity’s current official page describes the full photo-editing toolkit as free. Installation currently requires a Canva account, and premium Canva AI capabilities are optional.

Does PhotoCraft require an account?

The local PhotoCraft editor can be downloaded and used without an account. Optional ArtCraft cloud-generation plans require their own account and payment terms.

Which app is better for RAW photos?

Affinity Photo is the better fit in this comparison for RAW development and photography-specific processing. Test your camera formats and colour workflow before relying on either alternative.

Which is better for PSD files?

Affinity is the more mature production application, while PhotoCraft is more directly focused on layered PSD/PSB read and write. Validate the exact layer features you need in both applications.

Open source · Free

Try PhotoCraft on your own files.

Download the desktop build, keep your source documents, and compare the layers and output against your current workflow.

Sources and further reading

We use primary vendor and project sources for product features, licensing, and platform claims. PhotoCraft-specific technical details come from its public repository and release documentation.

  1. PhotoCraft source, documentation, and current limitations
  2. PhotoCraft v0.23.1 downloads, release notes, and checksums
  3. Affinity Photo official product page
  4. Adobe Photoshop official product page
PhotoCraft vs Affinity Photo: PSD Editor vs RAW Suite